It’s Not the Very Poor That Romney Doesn’t Care About, It’s the Working Poor

Let’s give Mitt Romney the benefit of the doubt: He didn’t really mean it when he said, “I’m not concerned about the very poor.” Or, let’s just say he cares about them no less than he cares about the rest of us. Only 41 percent of respondents in a recent poll said that Romney “cares about people like me,” so if the wisdom of crowds is any guide, the very poor are hardly unique as objects of his indifference.

Let’s look instead at Romney’s follow-up: That there’s a “safety net” for the very poor, and “if there are holes in it, I’ll fix them.” This isn’t just a walk-back of the “not concerned” comment. It represents a very real element of an emerging conservative argument, one that deserves to be taken seriously. In this antiquated vision of the economy, everything is fine for most people, but there is a slice of the “very poor” who might need some help. Poverty, in this vision, is the exception; prosperity and opportunity without government aid is the norm. (Jonathan Cohn noted yesterday that Romney and his party aren’t serious about repairing the safety net, but for our purposes, let’s take him at his word.)

In some ways, Romney’s poverty-exceptionalism is an old postwar liberal vision. John Kenneth Galbraith, in The Affluent Society, wrote about “islands” of poverty in the midst of plenty. Michael Harrington’s breakthrough in The Other America, which will celebrate its fiftieth anniversary this year, was to show that poverty was whiter and more widespread than Galbraith had assumed, touching perhaps 40 million people, which was still just one fifth of the country. (Today we’d call it “the 20%”.) William Julius Wilson, in his 1987 book The Truly Disadvantaged, called for a focus not so much on the breadth of poverty, but on its depth and intractability in one of Galbraith’s “islands,” the black inner-city. Much liberal philanthropy and social services are still driven by a vision not of the economy as a whole, but of poverty as a distinct and identifiable exception within an otherwise functioning system.

Often, it was conservatives and Republicans who challenged the poverty-exceptionalism of liberals. Ronald Reagan, for example, was a supporter of the Earned Income Tax Credit, which benefited not the very poor, but those who had low incomes even though they worked. Over the course of the 1980s and 1990s, both Republicans and Democrats gradually built out programs like Medicaid to extend beyond the poverty line, a long trend that culminated in the mandatory expansion of Medicaid by an estimated 16 million people in the Affordable Care Act, as well as the subsidies for people earning up to four times the poverty line. To the extent that the 1996 welfare reform “worked,” it was in part because of these expansions: They ensured that people wouldn’t automatically lose all their other supports if they moved from the ranks of welfare recipients to the working poor. The idea that the safety net could be a trap, unless some of its benefits were extended to the working poor and even beyond, was not purely a conservative idea, but it was a point of significant bipartisan agreement.

Romney, and a new group of conservative thinkers, have aggressively rejected this consensus. Romney attacks our current “entitlement society” as “a fundamental corruption of American society” because it provides benefits to a large swath of society. The “entitlement society,” Romney has said, “makes us all poor,” because it encourages so many of us to rely on the government for services. William Voegeli of the Claremont Institute has made a similar argument in his book, Never Enough: America’s Limitless Welfare State. The extension of benefits and supports to the working poor and beyond, Voegeli argues, knows no natural boundaries and will eventually consume all our resources. This new-ish argument is an extension of the claim made by deficit hawks such as David Walker of the Peter G. Peterson Foundation that an “entitlement crisis” is the cause of long-term budget deficits. But Romney, like Voegeli, takes it much, muchfurther: “The battle we face today is more than a fight over our budget. It is a battle for America’s soul.” Government programs for the non-poor, in other words, are not just expensive, but  actually detrimental to the vast majority of their beneficiaries.

Voegeli, like Romney, claims to support a strong safety net—as long as it’s exclusively for the very poor. So does Representative Paul Ryan, who argued in the Wall Street Journal last April that “the safety net for the poor is coming apart at the seams” and promised “a secure safety net” as part of his budget proposal. Like Romney, Ryan’s proposals don’t actually reflect this vision (his proposal to convert Medicaid to a block grant to the states, for example, would destroy that system for the very poor as well as the working poor), but what they claim to be doing is reducing government spending by focusing benefits on the “truly disadvantaged.” Meanwhile, those who aren’t truly disadvantaged are expected to somehow benefit from being left on their own. 

In taking up this new conservative line, Romney and others are trashing an important part of Reagan’s legacy and a significant bipartisan innovation over the past few decades. The idea of supporting and rewarding work and responsibility met up with the recognition that people need supports—health care, child care, income security—in order to take full advantage of opportunities after they leave the ranks of the “very poor.” And in the current economy, the working poor and near-poor need every bit of help they can get to avoid slipping further down. That’s probably much more true than when Harrington wrote, at a time when Americans above the poverty line were far more likely to belong to a union, have some job security, and have little debt. Today’s low-income workers bear far more risk of unemployment, health costs, and debt. Without protections such as Medicaid and job training, the proverbial “safety net” will be pitched so low that by the time people reach it, they will already have slipped off the main track of the economy. The need to look at the economy as a whole, in which poverty is not an exception but both the working poor and the very poor, along with a large portion of the rest of the 99%, are similarly struggling, is greater than ever.

Romney deserves mockery for his clumsy language. He deserves to be called out for the fact that he wouldn’t actually “repair” the safety net. But we should also recognize that there is an underlying vision to his mangled words, and that that vision marks a dramatic break from the conservative tradition. It’s also far out of step with what people need in order to participate in the modern American economy.

Comments (9)Add a comment

The battleground intended for enterprise Microsoft Windows 8 has become all set to shift where attributes could be rendered into Windows 8 solution excellent.


Among the many functions one Microsoft Office 2007 learns the best way t use with Office 2007 Training course is how to setup the Office 2007 Download slide show timer. This feature permits an individual to spotligh their audience and Office 2007 Professional never worry about thi presentation slides moving if they are MS Office 2007 needed.With all thes Generator options factored in, you are sure to search for the best application to you. One can established the timer to switch slides at the intervals they may be Microsoft Office 2007 Download speaking while creating the slide show.Office 2007 Key can get protect by putting in the register Antivirus, which can handle the Download Office 2007 attacks of your system.


Managers Microsoft Office Professional 2007 Product Key may refine and Windows 7 customize each part of the program for applicable used i their property fit. In the Surpas program, you can access formulas by Win 7 simply flipping through tab, insert charts in addition Download Windows 7 diagrams and import data quickly from sources you hook up with. It is very handy so that you ca access the functions you employ most with Buy Windows 7 this kind of ease, and Microsoft features clearly Microsoft Windows 7 research to make the most out from the Ribbons of each and every application.

Discount prada shoes are very important for virtually every male in her way of life. Prada America‘s Cup sneakers are essential for numerous requirements.This happens to most shoes prada men sneakers & prada high top sneaker that don’t offer any lace protection, though. Prada Shoulder Bags is every popular on the market .

Prada Purses many Prada specialist shoppers, could know the difference a duplicate prada Baggage from your prada Carriers because of its favorite songs produces, it is usually sincerely deafening while you extendable it again, a lot better in order to expansion it as well really you could possibly damage the whole case, only a bit of expansion can do, it produces any raucous special sound experience.Prada Patent Leather Shoes Men Black is made of black treated leather,it stout leather sole with skid-resistant function

Buying our cheap prada men casual shoes which are new arrivals provide latest styles and discount price for everyone.welcome to our prada shoes on sale online store to check the series styles and colors .

Discount prada shoes are very important for virtually every male in her way of life. Prada America‘s Cup sneakers are essential for numerous requirements.This happens to most shoes prada men sneakers & prada high top sneaker that don’t offer any lace protection, though. Prada Shoulder Bags is every popular on the market .

Prada Purses many Prada specialist shoppers, could know the difference a duplicate prada Baggage from your prada Carriers because of its favorite songs produces, it is usually sincerely deafening while you extendable it again, a lot better in order to expansion it as well really you could possibly damage the whole case, only a bit of expansion can do, it produces any raucous special sound experience.Prada Patent Leather Shoes Men Black is made of black treated leather,it stout leather sole with skid-resistant function

Buying our cheap prada men casual shoes which are new arrivals provide latest styles and discount price for everyone.welcome to our prada shoes on sale online store to check the series styles and colors .

Timberland Shoes retail store on the net sales Saying Timberland Roll-Top Shoes intended for Adult males. Timberland Classic 2 Eye Mens Lug Sole Boat Shoes Throw Major Shoes intended for Adult males can market including Timberland Boots sizzling cakes with your web page at all times. A method not like another.Not previously know to persuade Roger Garcia several times, but Roger Garcia did not listen. When something far, she was not too Guan Dele. But now is not the same, Roger Timberland Mens 6-Inch Premium Boots at his side, he can every day, ‘monitor’ her.

The two sisters looked at each other Timberland Men’s Chukka Boots and smiled, although they saw once a year the surface, but they did not let the two sisters become alienated. On the contrary, this dim feeling of the relationship between the two sisters is getting better and better.

A Timberland outlets Factory Outlet is really a place for individuals who adore Timberland options but have quite limited purchasing budget. Timberland 14 inches Boot styles retailer cheap Timberland Boots on the web selling Proverb Timberland Roll-Top Boot styles regarding Guys.

Timberland Shoes retail store on the net sales Saying Timberland Roll-Top Shoes intended for Adult males. Timberland Classic 2 Eye Mens Lug Sole Boat Shoes Throw Major Shoes intended for Adult males can market including Timberland Boots sizzling cakes with your web page at all times. A method not like another.Not previously know to persuade Roger Garcia several times, but Roger Garcia did not listen. When something far, she was not too Guan Dele. But now is not the same, Roger Timberland Mens 6-Inch Premium Boots at his side, he can every day, ‘monitor’ her.

The two sisters looked at each other Timberland Men’s Chukka Boots and smiled, although they saw once a year the surface, but they did not let the two sisters become alienated. On the contrary, this dim feeling of the relationship between the two sisters is getting better and better.

A Timberland outlets Factory Outlet is really a place for individuals who adore Timberland options but have quite limited purchasing budget. Timberland 14 inches Boot styles retailer cheap Timberland Boots on the web selling Proverb Timberland Roll-Top Boot styles regarding Guys.

To girls, nothing might be better than get one pair of beautiful shoes to be proud and attractive. These discount Louboutins available with nice and easygoing design. It is very easy to wear this discount 150mm Christian Louboutin Lady Peep in daily life. You deserve to have one or more pair for collection in this season.Christian louboutin daffodile are full of fashion taste, you can wear such shoes to party,also suitable for daily life.

Check out the main on your cheap red bottom 2012 shoes runner,Christian louboutin uk footwear is recognized in relation to red business! to aid you to put money on each and every phony will present a new burgandy particular. Christian Louboutin Bianca pumps are so practical that you all should buy one .You can dress yourself up by paying more attention to choose the right cheap louboutin shoes . Every woman fanaticizes of presenting herself in the best possible manner and to look really beautiful at Christian louboutin discount shoes.

As for my part, I think this discount newest Christian Louboutin Vicky 120mm Suede booty can apply to all kinds of occasion, allowing you to show characteristics and increased self-confidence freely. It was designed meticulously and specially for you. Buy one in our store with more discount and free shipping online. Just as christian louboutin pumps is really exclusive and sexy.

To girls, nothing might be better than get one pair of beautiful shoes to be proud and attractive. These discount Louboutins available with nice and easygoing design. It is very easy to wear this discount 150mm Christian Louboutin Lady Peep in daily life. You deserve to have one or more pair for collection in this season.Christian louboutin daffodile are full of fashion taste, you can wear such shoes to party,also suitable for daily life.

Check out the main on your cheap red bottom 2012 shoes runner,Christian louboutin uk footwear is recognized in relation to red business! to aid you to put money on each and every phony will present a new burgandy particular. Christian Louboutin Bianca pumps are so practical that you all should buy one .You can dress yourself up by paying more attention to choose the right cheap louboutin shoes . Every woman fanaticizes of presenting herself in the best possible manner and to look really beautiful at Christian louboutin discount shoes.

As for my part, I think this discount newest Christian Louboutin Vicky 120mm Suede booty can apply to all kinds of occasion, allowing you to show characteristics and increased self-confidence freely. It was designed meticulously and specially for you. Buy one in our store with more discount and free shipping online. Just as christian louboutin pumps is really exclusive and sexy.

Anyone can save about 49% compared with the Moncler men vests, coats, jackets, and other types of providers, a contract of sale in the den. Moncler Women Long Down Coats is not accustomed anorak.The covering is fabricated of a affable, animationable abscondce bric that is baptize and wind abideant.The discount moncler winter coats are hotsale online.The moncler clothing are well know for fashion,ease and value.

Moncler Gene Women Jackets new could be the top-level brand in the down jacket fashion globe. It is a reality that Moncler jackets are prevailing amongst a lot of superstars, practically every single superstar in Hollywood owns 1 Moncler jacket .These Moncler Clairy Two Tone Down Jackets new are packed with perfect material which could by no suggests provide your entire body a cooler affect. via these coats, you have chance to go outside, when cold breeze will be blowing. In winters, you and your loved ones would like to pick having some fun.

These days, we are referring on the Women Moncler Coats Safran Quilted High Gloss with excellent overall performance and classy design and style. Men Moncler Jackets with attractive models, they go very well with jeans and shorts simply.People are satisied with moncler winter coats , it sells well in the cold winter in our store.

Anyone can save about 49% compared with the Moncler men vests, coats, jackets, and other types of providers, a contract of sale in the den. Moncler Women Long Down Coats is not accustomed anorak.The covering is fabricated of a affable, animationable abscondce bric that is baptize and wind abideant.The discount moncler winter coats are hotsale online.The moncler clothing are well know for fashion,ease and value.

Moncler Gene Women Jackets new could be the top-level brand in the down jacket fashion globe. It is a reality that Moncler jackets are prevailing amongst a lot of superstars, practically every single superstar in Hollywood owns 1 Moncler jacket .These Moncler Clairy Two Tone Down Jackets new are packed with perfect material which could by no suggests provide your entire body a cooler affect. via these coats, you have chance to go outside, when cold breeze will be blowing. In winters, you and your loved ones would like to pick having some fun.

These days, we are referring on the Women Moncler Coats Safran Quilted High Gloss with excellent overall performance and classy design and style. Men Moncler Jackets with attractive models, they go very well with jeans and shorts simply.People are satisied with moncler winter coats , it sells well in the cold winter in our store.